In The Kitchen with Laura McKenna: The Best Grilled Cheese


November 1, 2024 12:16 PM CDT
By: Laura McKenna
Supported by
Sunday is National Sandwich Day and a survey was recently conducted to ask what people would choose as their favorite sandwich. The number one answer: Grilled Cheese!
So here’s some tips I’ve gathered over the years:
MAKE SURE BUTTER REACHES ALL THE WAY TO THE EDGE
This tip came from a former co-host of mine that swore that the key to the BEST grilled cheese sandwich was how you buttered it. I would tease him about his cooking skills and how he always ordered from the kid’s menu (haha) so I am willing to bet he knows a good grilled cheese!
USE MAYO INSTEAD OF BUTTER
I can’t remember who came up with this little trick but I’ve tried it and it’s not bad. It browns and caramelizes a little different than butter so it adds a unique flavor.
MY FAVORITE: ADD A LITTLE ZING
I know not everyone likes spicy things but a little pepperjack is my trick for the best grilled cheese. I’ll use an entire slice of pepperjack along with some cheddar or colby (but you can use American cheese if that’s what you like best). If adding an entire additional slice of pepperjack cheese would be a little too much for your tastebuds, just use a sprinkle of shredded pepperjack. It’s worth it!
Want to contact Laura McKenna about some of your favorite sandwich recipes or cooking tricks you do? Anything else on your mind? Email anytime, she’d love to hear from you: [email protected]
And tune in weekdays starting at 10am to St. Croix Country & WCFW!
More Articles By Laura McKenna

04.08.25
Recall Alert: Johnsonville Cheddar Bratwurst
As soon as baseball season begins, it’s time to fire up the grill. But before you place a bratwurst on there, make sure it’s not one of the packages involved in the bratwurst recall. I know I don’t have any of these at home (being a vegetarian and all) but the makers of Johnsonville brats […]
Read More >

04.07.25
Movie Monday: Pet Lovers, You’re About To Have Your Heart Melted
As you know I am a big time cat lover. Here’s my boy, Phil Dawson. I try to make him behave but who can say no to this little face? So I am both excited and bracing myself to just turn into a ball of mush with the upcoming documentary directed by Bryce Dallas Howard. […]
Read More >

04.01.25
In The Kitchen with Laura McKenna: Bread Making Tips
FUN FACT (that I don’t find very fun at all): Don’t slice bread while it’s still warm, fresh out of the oven! Honestly, this goes against everything I live for because bread hot out of the oven tastes THE BEST! But cutting off the first slice right away might make the rest of the loaf […]
Read More >

03.31.25
Movie Monday: The movie next in line for Hunger Games fans
Hunger Games fans can mark their calendars for November 20th, 2026. That’s when The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping will be released in movie theaters. The new prequel book centers on Haymitch (played in all the previous movies by Woody Harrelson) but casting hasn’t been released just yet for the movie. The book so […]
Read More >