In The Kitchen With Laura McKenna: How To Make A Heart Shaped Cake Without A Heart Shaped Pan


February 12, 2025 9:30 AM CT
By: Laura McKenna
Supported by
Love is in the air and I’m here to make your Valentine’s Day just a little sweeter!
Let’s make a Heart Shaped Cake for your honey. What’s that? You don’t have a special pan that bakes heart shaped cakes? No worries! You don’t need one.
I have an easy way to make a Heart Shaped Cake without having to buy a Heart Shaped Pan.
Most of us have a round cake pan (mine is an 9″) and a square brownie or cake pan (mine is an 8×8″). That’s all you need.

Whether you are using a boxed cake mix or your favorite recipe, split the batter evenly between the two pans and bake according to the directions.
Then let the heart-shaped magic happen when you take the cakes out of the oven. Flip the cakes out of their respective pans. Position the square cake more like a diamond. Then cut the round cake in half and place each piece on the top of your diamond to form a heart.

Frost that baby and no one will know you didn’t bake a heart shaped cake from the start!
Cake pans slightly different in size? Don’t stress. Just use more icing to patch in and even things up. Who doesn’t like a little extra, anyway?
Bonus Tip: If you’re worried about your square and half-circles separating while you cut the cake, just spread a little frosting in between your cake parts to act as a “glue” to hold them together.
Enjoy and have a Happy Valentine’s Day!
Want to contact Laura McKenna about some of your favorite recipes or baking tricks that you love to do? Anything else on your mind? Email anytime, she’d love to hear from you: Laura.McKenna@civicmedia.us
And tune in weekdays starting at 10am to St. Croix Country & WCFW!

More Articles By Laura McKenna

06.04.26
Recall Alert: Ford Vehicle Seatbelt Issues and DO NOT DRIVE Warning
First, we learned about a seat belt recall for certain Ford Expedition and Lincoln Navigator vehicles with model years 2018 through 2022. You can read more about that HERE. Now, there comes a DO NOT DRIVE WARNING for approximately 4,000 Ford vehicles. This seems to be from the lower control arm ball joint that may […]
Read More >

05.28.26
In The Kitchen with Laura McKenna: Grilling Temps
May 28th is National Burger Day and while I don’t know how many people would take meat grilling tips from a vegetarian, let me say this: I know how to do it… I just don’t eat it. For the safest way to grill, here’s what the pros recommend for internal grilling temps. Using a meat […]
Read More >

05.19.26
In The Kitchen with Laura McKenna: Grapes
You know I’m a big believer that food is medicine. And I’m also a huge fan of grapes. I snack on them pretty much daily. With summer sun on the horizon, a lot of people are worried about sun damage to their skin. Could grapes be the magical cure? Researchers at Western New England University […]
Read More >

05.18.26
Movie Monday: The famous Zoltar machine from “Big”
Do you remember the famous Zoltar fortune-telling machine from the 1988 movie, Big, starring Tom Hanks? Well, apparently there was a 56-year-old guy in Michigan who got some lotto numbers from a Zoltar machine and has been playing those same numbers for the last 30 years. And he finally just won! Stephen Huesgen got the […]
Read More >




